Michael Angelo’s Pizza

Reviews

• William R Ponsot

  star star star star star 7 June 2026

  May easily be the best "regular pie" in the neighborhood. NYC native saying this.... Lived in the area for nearly 10 years and rarely go 2 weeks without ordering from here. Have had a lot of different delivery guys over the years so "cheese slide" is sometimes a factor. They get very busy during peak hours but mostly get quick service. Give them a shot sometimes.

• Debbie Doris

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 27 May 2026

  What can i say? Pizza wasn’t good at all, very dry no taste. The atmosphere is not welcoming at all. Not sure what all the hype is about average pizza no better that frozen Elliot’s pizza.

• Cindy Brady

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  Just awful pizza food and service. Waited over an hour for slices that came soggy and tasted awful. Save your money eat elsewhere. Awful decor to

• Gordana Bacac

  star star star star star 19 May 2026

  This restaurant is something to brag about! The atmosphere is so cozy and warm as well as the waiters and workers, everyone is so polite and welcoming! The owners are remarkable there are no words that can explain !!!The food is out of this world! Believe me when you go in you won’t go out hungry !!! I was so stuffed I couldn’t even order desert!!!! The best part is is that they host parties!!! Michael Angelos has outdoor eating as well!!! What they did with the place is remarkable !!! Love it ❤️love it ❤️love it ❤️ Five stars all the way !!!!🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

• Michael Le

  star star star_border star_border star_border 15 May 2026

  Came here and ordered a regular cheese pizza and fried calamari. I had read many reviews and people rave about the pizza. I wanted to try and decided to this night cause I saw their menu out in front of the restaurant, which advertised a special on the pizza. So, I go in, order the pizza and the calamari and was charged more than what I was expecting. When I pointed to the special on the menu, they said that the special was no longer valid. I told them it's sitting out front, how can it not be valid? Reluctantly, the guy checking me out went over to the guy in the kitchen (who I assume is the owner) and asked what to do. He was approved to give me the special price, "just this one time." I went by a week or so later and the menu is still out front with the special price still printed on it. As far as the pizza and calamari go, the pizza was average at best. I would say my homemade pizza blows it out of the water. Even at the special price, it wasn't worth the money. The calamari was also average and wasn't anything special. Pretty basic fare with no stand out qualities. It was my first experience, but the fact that they are advertising specials that they may or may not grant on a whim leaves me with a bad taste. Add to that the seemingly average quality of the pizza and there's no reason for me to return. Shame.